logoalt Hacker News

pavlovyesterday at 8:55 AM4 repliesview on HN

Is there a more bizarre legislative process anywhere in the world?

The US Congress is practically able to pass only a single giant bill every year. To work around its own deficit rules, these bills are packed with taxation time bombs where rules have expiration dates or delayed starts several years in the future.

Then, if Congress doesn’t get around to defusing its own time bombs, you get situations like this R&D expensing fiasco where American businesses and employees pay the price. Unless the bomb is hopefully retroactively cancelled, like happened now.

On top of this madness, there’s an executive branch operating like a runaway autocracy, producing a flood of executive orders that intentionally flaunt laws and even target specific private entities (e.g. Trump’s attacks on law firms that worked for his opponents, and universities he doesn’t like).

How long can a nation function like this? If the bond market loses faith in this process, there could be mayhem. Will be interesting to see if the passage of BBB impacts US debt when markets open again on Monday.


Replies

andrekandretoday at 2:09 AM

  > taxation time bombs where rules have expiration dates or delayed starts several years in the future.
  > ...
  > Unless the bomb is hopefully retroactively cancelled, like happened now.
this is by design: the opposition usually get into power in midterms and next presidency can swap parties, so if there is a bad provision its moved out to "explode" when they aren't in power and hurt the oppositions continuing chances

as an example, the cuts to medicade don't start until right after the next midterms (which most are expecting to strongly favor democrats) [0]

[0] https://ccf.georgetown.edu/2025/05/27/medicaid-and-chip-cuts...

jayd16yesterday at 7:23 PM

The unserious and corrupt are consistently rewarded with re-election. I really have no idea how we move forward.

show 1 reply
kzrdudeyesterday at 3:52 PM

It's a year of very rapid change. I just realized the other week (naively) that we (non-US) should really be bracing even more than we are. For shocks to come, economical, cultural as a reaction to the slide towards an authoritarian presidential system.

It's not a time to be watching though, but to act.

kevin_thibedeauyesterday at 11:05 AM

Congress has transformed from a body of civil servants working toward a common goal to a bunch of solipsist narcissists happy to burn everything down for more face time in the beltway media echo chamber.