logoalt Hacker News

9283409232last Saturday at 8:29 PM2 repliesview on HN

If I recall the problem with approval voting is that it is much easier to tamper with than RCV. Filling in an empty bubble is a lot easier than changing the order of ranking on a ballot


Replies

nerdsniperlast Saturday at 9:08 PM

That’s a good point. Seems like that could be a problem for current ballots too - add a second checkmark to invalidate ballots voting for the “other” guy. Doesn’t seem to be a widespread issue, but detecting it for current ballots would be more obvious.

Maybe that breaks this idea. Maybe ideally you’d maybe want a touchscreen+printer to fill in the bubbles with printer ink and show it to the voter for them to double-check before putting in the stack (or, if wrong bubble filled, put it in rejected stack).

Would love more feedback from people to get a better sense of all pros and cons.

show 2 replies
ClayShentruplast Sunday at 11:50 PM

it's utterly the opposite of that.

http://scorevoting.net/StratHonMix