logoalt Hacker News

Expurplelast Saturday at 6:40 AM1 replyview on HN

> What are the outcomes that we are talking about here?

Living a life free of guilt and regrets. People make mistakes and can't foresee everything. That's normal. That shouldn't imply any guilt. I was talking specifically about cases where, in advance, you think that you're doing the wrong thing at the cost of short-term convenience.

Regarding KHTML, I don't have any data and can't say for sure. But I'd be surprised if most developers regretted their decision later. They knew in advance that they were getting into an LGPL project that can be used as part of something freedom-restricting. And, in my subjective opinion, Safari isn't so catastrofic and harmful that it defies common expectations of how harmful a freedom-restricting product can be


Replies

rglullislast Saturday at 11:10 AM

> Living a life free of guilt and regrets.

Sorry, this is not an outcome. Maybe you can say it's an strategy to help you define your priorities and it can help you set your goals in whatever endeavor you're taking on, but it's not something that has a clear goal post.

> Safari isn't so catastrophic and harmful

Taken in isolation, no it's not so bad. But the issues of Safari are the context where its development happens. Safari is intentionally stripped of any feature that could threaten Apple's market dominance in the mobile market.

And that is the problem with too-permissive software licenses.