logoalt Hacker News

RamblingCTO07/31/20254 repliesview on HN

I really don't get it. It's against the German constitution and yet there are still politicians pushing for that, again and again. We should make it mandatory that when something is clearly against the constitution you loose your job as a politician. It won't work anyway. It's the same spiel wasting so much money and time. Do we know which lobby group/party is pushing for that yet again?


Replies

graemep07/31/2025

Is it clearly against the constitution?

What happens when the constitution clashes with EU law?

Can the constitution be amended and is it likely if there is a clash with EU law on this issue?

Enormous pressure can be brought to bear in politicians over something like this. The most prominent British politician to oppose the Online Safety Act in the UK is being labelled as "helping people like Jimmy Saville" by the government (Saville was a TV presenter and notorious child abuser) .

show 3 replies
nickslaughter0208/01/2025

> Do we know which lobby group/party is pushing for that yet again?

tldr: A US based surveillance company called Thorn has been lobbying for this for years.

‘Who Benefits?’ Inside the EU’s Fight over Scanning for Child Sex Content https://balkaninsight.com/2023/09/25/who-benefits-inside-the...

Chat control & Kutcher: Ombudsman criticizes secrecy https://www.heise.de/en/news/Chat-control-Kutcher-Ombudsman-...

derelicta07/31/2025

A constitution is just a piece of paper. The ruling class can discard it as they wish.

show 1 reply
betaby07/31/2025

> It's against the German constitution

No one cares. Like anywhere in the world.

show 2 replies