logoalt Hacker News

sidewndr4607/31/20256 repliesview on HN

One of the failings of most modern democracies is that if a measure doesn't pass, nothing prohibits it from being introduced again immediately. I've seen ballot initiatives simply get copy pasted onto each election by city council until they happen to pass.


Replies

ryandrake07/31/2025

The deck is stacked. They only have to win once, and it's law. You have to win over and over every time it's introduced.

show 3 replies
soulofmischief07/31/2025

A well-funded institution will always outlast an individual or smaller organization in a war of attrition. I think a modern Constitution needs to consider 19-20th-century concepts such as game theory if it has any hope of preventing eventual corruption.

show 2 replies
deaddodo07/31/2025

Meanwhile, they make the dismantling of legislation near impossible. You have to go through the same process, but in inverse; and hope that miraculously the representatives in gov't become altruistic with a desire for less power.

mc3207/31/2025

It'd be nice if bills were one item only and on failure or passage, there would be a timeout before it could be brought to vote again either to try to pass it again or to repeal it. Like at least a year. For some things maybe five years.

Kim_Bruning07/31/2025

That's what constitutional amendments are for, right? (or in this case ECHR updates)

show 1 reply
noqc07/31/2025

This system would make a lot more sense if the number of people you had to get to agree to a bill with a bunch of riders was more than 50%.