logoalt Hacker News

jimmaswell07/31/20253 repliesview on HN

This one is a stretch. 'Dark pattern' makes me think of something like a burglar hiding in the darkness of shadows or nighttime, not race.

And the website in question is hosted by the Australian government, American censorship doesn't come into the picture..


Replies

rapnie07/31/2025

Thanks, I updated the text putting the US bit in parentheses.

For black-list/white-list replacing with block-list/allow-list (also more descriptive) is a a clearer example of the rationale to change the terminology. In general it is about the whole range of feelings and perceptions around "dark" and how they lead to biases in people, often without being aware. If we become conditioned that uses of "dark" invoke gut feelings of sneaky, shady, illegal, secretive, nefarious, evil, etc. some of that may seep through in how people with dark skin are considered. Whether that is true or not, in any case, the alternative terminology being more descriptive, it is low-hanging fruit to adopt it.

show 2 replies
zzo38computer07/31/2025

I agree that "dark pattern" does not to me think of race, either, but I think that "deceptive design" is a better word anyways.

adamhartenz08/01/2025

It is not really about what it directly means. It is about changing the social ideas of white or lighter things meaning good, while black or darker things meaning bad.