logoalt Hacker News

gwd08/01/20253 repliesview on HN

Then why even bother calling it "left" at this point? Just say they're anti-monopoly. Is there really nobody on the right who are also anti-monopoly?


Replies

shazbotter08/01/2025

Presumably because anti monopoly right is much less common? Or because the anti monopoly right is concerned with different aspects of monopoly?

If someone said they were anti monopoly, that the government should do something to prevent businesses from operating like that, I'd never expect them to be from the right to be honest.

show 1 reply
ozgrakkurt08/01/2025

Tbh classification that makes most sense is wealth level.

Ultra rich and very rich and rich and upper middle class and ..

mft_08/01/2025

Because the underlying beliefs of a 'left' anti-monopolist and a 'right' anti-monopolist are likely very different, and similarly their proposed solutions and view of an ideal society will also diverge significantly?

---

Also, it should be noted that we lack sufficiently concise but specific terms to use instead, and because alternative terms that are used are relative, and open to interpretation.

e.g.:

Many political commentators currently use the term "populist" to describe someone who's somewhat divergent from the capitalist political mainstream (and in US terms, I'd include the current Democrat establishment and traditional non-MAGA Republicans in this group). But when the term is applied to people as diverse as Corbyn, Sanders, and AOC on the one side, and Orban, Farage, and Trump on the other, it's nonsensical without much more explanation.

show 1 reply