logoalt Hacker News

tghccxs08/01/20252 repliesview on HN

Do you think this specific criticism of the “populist left” by the “abundance liberals” is valid though?


Replies

bb8675408/01/2025

No, this guy (the writer of the article) has no idea what he’s talking about. I say this as someone isn’t even on the left.

He sets a false dichotomy to protect himself from criticism. Zoning/building codes being too strict and monopolies existing in that market aren’t incompatible.

It’s worth noting that there’s a lot of money behind this abundance movement or whatever, so that’s something to take into account when reading this stuff.

thrance08/01/2025

Truthfully, I don't. IMHO, abundance liberalism has a blind spot when it comes to the power of money in modern politics. We didn't stumble into a situation where buying a house requires an entire lifetime of work out of sheer bad luck. Some private interests greatly benefit from this situation and have enough power to keep things from changing.

Until we address this, and the abundance crowd doesn't want to, all of this is pointless bickering.

show 1 reply