logoalt Hacker News

Tiktaalik08/01/20251 replyview on HN

> Jane Jacobs veto

As an aside, puts on Jane Jacobs defender hat I just want to point out that Jane Jacobs was on the record with the assertion that an ideal urban fabric was effectively small apartment buildings at densities well beyond what your typical North American city and suburb currently has.

It's deeply sad that Boomers took her ideas and distorted her message to preserve an ultra low density single family detached housing status quo.

https://viewpointvancouver.ca/2012/06/01/jane-jacobs-style-d...


Replies

camgunz08/01/2025

Hey I think she was basically right (I think her ideas on local control are applicable way beyond building neighborhoods). But we have to admit the ability to get up at some board meeting and veto stuff was her idea. It wasn't perverted by people who came after. Jacob's herself used these veto points in her time in Toronto. I'm not saying she was wrong to oppose the stuff she opposed, but the ability to obstruct in this way was her idea.

show 1 reply