logoalt Hacker News

TOGoSlast Sunday at 7:08 AM6 repliesview on HN

The demo video doesn't seem to have any audio in it! At least none that either ffmpeg or whatever Firefox uses can recognize.


Replies

noisem4kerlast Sunday at 8:34 AM

It's probably due to the unusual sound format, 24kHz mono PCM, and the fact that it was somehow forced into a WebM container, which only supports Vorbis and Opus officially.

It looks like the author created it using the "higher quality" ffmpeg command line, except for the "webm" final extension, producing the opposite of what's described as "an MP4 file that's compatible with more devices".

https://github.com/denizsafak/abogen/tree/main/demo#for-high...

ertianlast Sunday at 7:43 AM

Yeah, I've run a local Kokoro instance, and it doesn't work with Firefox. This uses Kokoro under the hood.

show 1 reply
jamiltonlast Sunday at 7:35 AM

Same here, but it worked when I opened it in Chrome. What a weird error - you would think that playing an embedded mp4 with audio wouldn't differ from browser to browser.

show 1 reply
frumiousirclast Sunday at 10:38 AM

Thanks for this. I thought I had some local issue with waterfox. Pasting the (long) video URL to the terminal let's mpv play it with audio.

Daunklast Sunday at 7:16 AM

Same on my end, no audio in the video.

huseyinkeleslast Sunday at 7:12 AM

I can hear it on safari