logoalt Hacker News

Sunlight-activated material turns PFAS in water into harmless fluoride

77 pointsby bookofjoelast Sunday at 4:31 PM28 commentsview on HN

Comments

nick238last Sunday at 5:24 PM

The Materials Science Gameplay Loop:

1. Invent fantastic new material that does a heretofore novel reaction or one with improved performance (chemical, photovoltaic, etc.)

2. Do #1 without lead, cadmium, mercury, or arsenic.

SociallyAwesomeAwkwardPenguinMeme("Turns PFAS to fluoride", "Contains Cadmium")

show 2 replies
pxeger1last Sunday at 7:14 PM

Ignoring the cadmium problem, is fluoride really harmless? I don't know what concentration of fluoride you'd end up with from converting typical PFAS pollution, but if you get enough fluoride it is acutely poisonous, which might be worse than the carcinogenic PFAS. (Likewise, it might be worse for the environment)

show 2 replies
ChrisMarshallNYlast Sunday at 9:31 PM

Fluoride?!!

Isn't that supposed to be some kind of demonic juice?

Why else is the government so intent on making sure that there's none in our water? I'm sure that they would much rather have the PFAS, produced by their nice, generous, industrialist bros.

show 1 reply
nraynaudlast Sunday at 6:33 PM

I'm a bit confused, are they suggesting that a cadnium coumpound to treat PFAS is a done deal?

tstrimplelast Sunday at 5:57 PM

[flagged]

show 1 reply