logoalt Hacker News

andyjohnson0last Sunday at 8:29 PM4 repliesview on HN

> With LLMs being unable to count how many Bs are in blueberry, they clearly don't have any world model whatsoever.

Is this a real defect, or some historical thing?

I just asked GPT-5:

    How many "B"s in "blueberry"?
and it replied:

    There are 2 — the letter b appears twice in "blueberry".
I also asked it how many Rs in Carrot, and how many Ps in Pineapple, amd it answered both questions correctly too.

Replies

libraryofbabellast Sunday at 8:53 PM

It’s a historical thing that people still falsely claim is true, bizarrely without trying it on the latest models. As you found, leading LLMs don’t have a problem with it anymore.

show 3 replies
bgwalterlast Sunday at 9:04 PM

It is not historical:

https://kieranhealy.org/blog/archives/2025/08/07/blueberry-h...

Perhaps they have a hot fix that special cases HN complaints?

show 1 reply
ThrowawayR2last Sunday at 8:59 PM

It was discussed and reproduced on GPT-5 on HN couple of days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44832908

Sibling poster is probably mistakenly thinking of the strawberry issue from 2024 on older LLM models.

nosioptarlast Sunday at 9:14 PM

Shouldn't the correct answer be that there is not a "B" in "blueberry"?

show 1 reply