logoalt Hacker News

rkomorn08/10/20253 repliesview on HN

It sounds like it's "the maximum penalty must be at least 1 year", as in "your member state can't enact a law where the maximum penalty is less than 1 year".

At least that's how I read it, but it's confusing.


Replies

H8crilAlast Monday at 1:00 AM

This is correct. But the larger point is that even 1 minute of jail time for such "crimes" is unacceptable.

show 3 replies
ameliuslast Monday at 11:33 AM

How would you have read it if it said "with a maximum of one year"?

show 1 reply
philwelchlast Monday at 1:03 AM

So it’s a minimum maximum.