logoalt Hacker News

munksbeerlast Monday at 10:51 AM2 repliesview on HN

Then you have understood even less. The commission act on instructions from the council. The steer for this has come from the member states, not the commission.


Replies

elriclast Monday at 12:02 PM

So what you're saying is: countries elect politicians in national elections, some of these politicians (typically the prime ministers) form the European Council, they propose a President of the Commission, the ruling government of each country then proposes one unelected Commissioner to join that Commission.

I still think it's fair to say that the Commission does not represent the people. It is many steps removed from the people. Nobody voted for any of them.

According to wikipedia, this point of view makes me a euroskeptic. Which is not something I consider myself to be, I'm a big proponent of cooperation between European countries. But I am certainly very skeptical of unelected government officials deciding on far reaching legislation that infringes upon fundamental liberties. With zero political repurcussions or liability.

show 1 reply
vaylianlast Monday at 11:16 AM

Counterpoint: The head of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, sits both in the European Commission and in the European Council. And it's UvdL who is the primary driving force for chat control at this point.

show 1 reply