logoalt Hacker News

miroljublast Monday at 2:04 PM3 repliesview on HN

It's exactly 250 € per child. If you are sustaining your life expenses yourself, it's just a small fraction of your tax money you get back. Fake asylum seekrs don't pay anything, hey just get support and procreate. They are a financial net negative for the society.

The system as is is encouraging the wrong kind of children, where children are assets for non-working, and a liability for working people.

First thing I would do to fix this is to remove child support handouts in cash. I would make it a tax credit instead, so only people who do productive work and pay taxes would get tax benefits.


Replies

BriggyDwiggs42last Monday at 5:48 PM

“Get government benefits and mooch off the dole” just doesn’t sound like a realistic portrayal of an asylum seeker, whether real or just for economic opportunity. Germany might be different, but I know in America all our immigrants are crazy hardworking.

show 1 reply
4gotunameagainlast Monday at 5:50 PM

You are not wrong there, but let me remind you that Germany has had a fertility rate lower than replacement since 1970. I don't think disincentivising anyone would be the way to go.

GuinansEyebrowslast Monday at 8:37 PM

> the wrong kind of children

this is a disturbing phrase