logoalt Hacker News

energy123today at 1:02 AM1 replyview on HN

Everything is just a low resolution representation of a thing. The so-called reality we supposedly have access to is at best a small number of sound waves and photons hitting our face. So I don't buy this argument that symbols are categorically different. It's a gradient and symbols are more sparse and less rich of a data source, yes. But who are we to say where that hypothetical line exists, beyond which further compression of concepts into smaller numbers of buckets becomes a non-starter for intelligence and world modelling. And then there's multi modal LLMs which have access to data of a similar richness that humans have access to.


Replies

bithive123today at 1:49 AM

There are no "things" in the universe. You say this wave and that photon exist and represent this or that, but all of that is conceptual overlay. Objects are parts of speech, reality is undifferentiated quanta. Can you point to a particular place where the ocean becomes a particular wave? Your comment already implies an understanding that our mind is behind all the hypothetical lines; we impose them, they aren't actually there.