logoalt Hacker News

bootsmannyesterday at 9:46 AM1 replyview on HN

I feel like refutations like this (you aren't using the tool right | you should try this other tool) pop up often but are fundamentally worthless because as long as you're not showing code you might as well be making it up. The blog post gives examples of clear failures that can be reproduced by anyone by themselves, I think its time vibe code defenders are held to the same standard.


Replies

adastra22yesterday at 2:52 PM

The very first example is that LLMs lose their mental model of chess when playing a game. Ok, so instead ask Claude Code to design an MCP for tracking chess moves, and vibe code it. That’s the very first thing that comes to mind, and I expect it would work well enough.