logoalt Hacker News

fellowmartianlast Monday at 2:14 AM3 repliesview on HN

I’m not suggesting grandpa reads code, contributors do. We all know that most commercial code is much shittier than open source. Sure, commercial code usually covers more edge cases and has better UX, but is cobbled together from legacy and random product asks.


Replies

positron26last Monday at 2:46 AM

> contributors do

More users != more contributors. As software gets more popular, you begin getting 10, 100, 1000, 1,000,000 users for every contributor.

This doesn't just affect non-programmers. We can't even police NPM.

People want it to be true so that it will be a talking point, but it's not true, and we need to find new talking points that align with facts that are evident outside the echo chambers.

show 1 reply
jen20last Monday at 2:55 AM

> We all know that most commercial code is much shittier than open source

Citation needed. Seriously.

show 1 reply
ranger_dangerlast Monday at 2:29 AM

> contributors do

I would argue most code of any license is not actually regularly audited if at all, and certainly nowhere near the levels people seem to think they are.

> We all know that most commercial code is much shittier than open source

citation needed

show 1 reply