logoalt Hacker News

AdieuToLogicyesterday at 4:21 AM4 repliesview on HN

>> But I have had a feeling of "I came back" which I have solely after waking up from anasthaesia.

> These sound like anaesthetic side effects.

General anesthesia[0] used in surgeries are effectively artificially induced comas. The pre-op discussion with the anesthesiologist includes them describing this and that there is a very real risk that you will die from its usage.

Regaining consciousness after having it applied most certainly invokes a feeling of "I came back" and has nothing to do with side effects.

Source: I have had two general anesthesia[0] and one epidural[1] surgeries.

0 - https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/anesthesia/about...

1 - https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/treatments/21896-epidu...


Replies

zozbot234yesterday at 5:22 AM

The feeling of blinking out and suddenly being "back" is far from exclusive to comas or general anesthesia; it has been replicated via deep meditation. Specifically, it seems to be the core feature of what's technically known as nirodha samapatti (lit. "attainment of ceasing").

An easy way of intuiting what it might feel like (if imperfectly, of course) is just keeping a high state of lucidity and mental focus whilst you're naturally drifting in and out of light sleep; this might seem challenging at first but it's actually quite doable.

show 1 reply
modelessyesterday at 7:46 AM

OK but you haven't provided any trustworthy evidence, just a personal anecdote. This is not convincing, especially since some anaesthetics have known long term psychological effects. There's no reason to believe that a person experiencing them would correctly identify the cause intuitively. In fact that would be extremely surprising.

myself248yesterday at 5:36 PM

Does general anesthesia affect memory? I swear my ability to form memories fell off a cliff after a procedure years ago. Going in is the last thing I vividly remember and everything since is hazy or ephemeral.

nashashmiyesterday at 6:06 AM

I have a theory that some people don’t fully wake up after the anesthesia wears off. A part of them is still sleeping. Like memory bank takes a slow break and stops working. I suspect it happened to me and now I am looking for answers.

show 2 replies