logoalt Hacker News

tpoacheryesterday at 3:51 PM1 replyview on HN

Not pretending to be an expert in either system's internals, but I feel like svn would be a much better fit than git for this.

I find svn to be wonderful. There seems to be a real phobia against it which I've never understood and it's such a shame.

Especially when one of the biggest arguments "against" it is that "it's centralised" (when in fact using it in a decentralised manner is trivial), and ironically most people these days just use git as an interface to github (rather than the other way round), effectively using it in centralised manner.


Replies

hiAndrewQuinnyesterday at 4:15 PM

We'd probably see more SVN adoption if we had better ways to map it back and forth to a high quality Git repo. Even the minimal work I did writing [1] taught me the data models diverge in pretty fundamental ways. Can't blame people for being conservative around something at bedrock as their version control.

[1]: https://andrew-quinn.me/reposurgeon/