logoalt Hacker News

serial_devyesterday at 7:22 PM4 repliesview on HN

Alexa consistently fails with the simplest of questions.

Only thing it can do is set a timer, turn off a light and play music.

It is still nice, but it’s so frustrating when a question pops into my mind, and I accidentally ask Alexa just to get reminded yet again how useless it is for everything but the most basic tasks.

And no, I won’t pay 240 dollars a year so that I can get a proper response to my random questions that I realistically have only about once a week.


Replies

WaltPurvisyesterday at 10:04 PM

> Only thing it can do is set a timer, turn off a light

And it can't even do that without an Internet connection. As someone who experiences annoyingly frequent outages, it never ceases to boggle my mind that I have a $200 computer, with an 8" monitor and everything, that can't even understand "set a timer for 10 minutes" on its own.

show 1 reply
seviuyesterday at 7:31 PM

and despite all this, I would pay 240$ a year so that Siri can reliably do what Alexa does today

oh the irony

ghaffyesterday at 9:25 PM

Alexa has pretty much zero value for me.

Being able to just order something with zero shipping has a ton of value. I could drive down the street but it would still be an hour at the end of the day.

Video streaming has some value but there are a lot of options.

bboygravityyesterday at 7:27 PM

Just pay 0 USD and use Grok app for free?

By far the best thing currently available.

show 2 replies