logoalt Hacker News

X-ray scans reveal the hidden risks of cheap batteries

147 pointsby CharlesWlast Saturday at 6:37 PM51 commentsview on HN

Comments

xnxyesterday at 2:03 PM

14 days ago | 120 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45364932

show 2 replies
whycomeyesterday at 3:46 PM

It's kinda crazy that we don't yet have an approval process for "flight safe" batteries.

show 3 replies
diobyesterday at 2:55 PM

I actually had a battery for a drill meltdown on me earlier this year. If I hadn't been home (and it hadn't been on my stone counter when it happened), I probably wouldn't have a home.

show 7 replies
tristoryesterday at 3:56 PM

Reading the original report in the dupe from 14 days ago, it seems pretty clear that the conclusion is that counterfeit/low-cost lithium batteries are a safety hazard, and we should probably have stricter import regulations for batteries to shutdown the counterfeit/gray-market operations, as they are a serious fire hazard.

ckoyesterday at 6:20 PM

I once watched a video of a man holding what looked to be a bicycle battery walking into an elevator. After the doors closed, it seemed to have exploded and burst into flame in his hands, and the aftermath was charred remains.

After seeing this I refuse to sleep near my 20,000 mAh power bank. I saw this Jackery power station for sale for an ultra discounted price and noticed it was not lithium iron phosphate and I noped so fast.

show 2 replies
oulipo2yesterday at 4:32 PM

The main risk factor is cells, you have to source them from reputable manufacturers. After having monitored a few battery fires, we went on to design a casing with multiple features to contain fires, you can check it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v0NXXfCA2CY

If you're interested, you can order them here https://infinite-battery.com

show 1 reply
metalmanyesterday at 4:30 PM

There will always be a realy fucking bad failure mode attached to any energy dense storage medium. This is basic physics. The diffrence between a roaring fire in the wood stove, your car engine, an ultra high tech rocket motor and a bomb, is only the speed of the "flame front" A battery has the same issues, in that the higher the energy density and the greater the expected rate of energy transfer, the greater the chance of finding a way to detonate all the energy at once, which is actualy possible ,with a wood stove, if things go exactly wrong.Exceptionaly large explosions have happened with nothing more than dust, or flour. 4 things, you can pick 3. fast, powerfull, cheap, safe.

show 1 reply