logoalt Hacker News

duttishyesterday at 4:58 AM5 repliesview on HN

Wait what. I thought half the point of usb c was to not rely on orientation.

Is there any way to check this other than experiment?

My "solution" so far has been to not buy cheap cables and just hope I get quality in return.


Replies

lmmyesterday at 6:06 AM

> I thought half the point of usb c was to not rely on orientation. > Is there any way to check this other than experiment?

Well sure, a standards-compliant cable will work in either orientation, but it's always possible for some but not all of the pins or wires to break.

pjayesterday at 7:41 AM

I believe USB C cables actually do have an orientation - it's just that the negotiation both ends do usually makes that orientation irrelevant.

Maybe the negotiation can fail & the plugged in orientation is then the only one that works?

show 1 reply
tennysontyesterday at 5:10 AM

I think that I have a specific cable-device-orientation that is broken. Meaning, I think a particular USB C cable won't charge my phone if it's plugged in 'backwards'.

I always assumed that USB C cables use different pins depending on orientation, and that some pins on the cable wore down.

Maybe that's what happened here?

show 1 reply
cyberaxyesterday at 5:47 AM

It happens. More often than not, it can be physical damage or manufacturing defect for one of the contacts and/or wires.