logoalt Hacker News

oneplaneyesterday at 6:44 PM4 repliesview on HN

This is just a Windows VM with extra tooling. Makes it look slick, doesn't make it "Windows apps on Linux".

Similar projects exist for gaming for example Looking Glass, which also uses a Windows VM on KVM (the "Windows in Docker" thing is a bit of a lie, Windows doesn't run in the container, Windows runs on KVM on the host kernel).

UX wise, this is similar to RAIL.

That's not to say that this isn't neat, but it's also not something new (we still have two flavours: API simulation/re-implementation and running the OS [windows]). If this was a new, third flavour, that would be quite the news (in-place ABI translation?).


Replies

LennyHenrysNutstoday at 1:06 AM

And I had to come here to find out what it actually was. Why don't project pages ever actually tell you what it is, what it does and how it does it?

Half the time it's something like "Plorglewurzle leverages your big data block chain to provide sublinear microservices to Azure Cloud infrastructures"

At least this one kind of shows you having to install Windows.

show 2 replies
userbinatoryesterday at 7:31 PM

Missed opportunity to call it "Linux Subsystem for Windows", or LSW in short.

show 2 replies
heavyset_goyesterday at 7:06 PM

It's literally just dockur/windows:latest + FreeRDP rootless mode + a small daemon that runs in the VM that tells you what apps are installed via an API.

If you don't want the latter part, you'd be better served with the dockur/windows image + FreeRDP

show 2 replies
senectus1yesterday at 11:53 PM

and with MS making sure you have to sign in with a MS account... i dont really see the point of this.

show 1 reply