> One easy free-market-friendly libertarian-approved solution would give citizens and residents of California a choice - your data can be kept private, or you can get a sizeable precentage of the value if you opt-in to data collection and sharing.
Good luck operationalizing that
Some business models that depend on unscrutinized unlawful or antisocial behavior turn out to be unviable when they're forced to operate in a way that is lawful / not an attack on the public.