logoalt Hacker News

jvanderbotlast Saturday at 3:26 PM3 repliesview on HN

For position (opinion) or review (summarizing state of art and often laden with opinions on categories and future directions). LLMs would be happy to generate both these because they require zero technical contributions, working code, validated results, etc.


Replies

Sharlinlast Saturday at 3:47 PM

Right, good clarification.

naaskinglast Saturday at 5:59 PM

So what? People are experimenting with novel tools for review and publication. These restrictions are dumb, people can just ignore reviews and position papers if they start proving to be less useful, and the good ones will eventually spread through word of mouth, just like arxiv has always worked.

show 1 reply
bjournelast Saturday at 6:41 PM

If you believe that, can you demonstrate how to generate a position or review paper using an LLM?

show 3 replies