logoalt Hacker News

analog8374last Saturday at 6:41 PM3 repliesview on HN

Dementedness is higher in cities then, right?

What differences in behavior do we see between city and rural?


Replies

culilast Saturday at 9:17 PM

Probably not true per capita. In the suburb I partially grew up with they would kidnap homeless people and bus them to the nearest city. This is quite common throughout California and many red states.

Suburbs have more cars per capita, more driving in general, more asphalt,[0] more time commuting/being on the streets to reach common destinations, more exposure to smoke from fires, and sometimes even more exposure to pollutants and pesticides from farming (especially if they have golf courses. Golf courses use about 5x more pesticides than farmland per acre). Suburbs also have more suicides per capita than cities

[0] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03043...

show 1 reply
Spooky23yesterday at 2:55 AM

It’s really hard to study because population is so diffuse and sometimes don’t align with geography.

My mom used to work in public health research, and one example that was hard to quantify was suspected cancer clusters around roads that were oiled gravel, where the oil was contaminated with industrial waste products. Basically, people who were outside in the summer near a road seemed to get lung cancer at higher rates due to road dust.

Issue was there just weren’t enough people or documentation of the supply chain to really prove it. They were able to stop the process of “donating” waste products to the highway departments.

In an urban environment, it’s easy. There are probably 500,000 people living along busy commercial corridors in NYC where you can reliably measure stuff like exposure to diesel particles or whatever.

antistheneslast Saturday at 7:35 PM

[flagged]

show 3 replies