logoalt Hacker News

fweimerlast Saturday at 7:26 PM4 repliesview on HN

The images are generated because it's a concept only:

> This is a design concept and no concrete implementation is currently planned.

https://www.apg.at/en/projects/austrian-power-giants-1/

They don't say whether their design takes practical concerns into account and preserve the functional aspects that gave the pylons their current shape.


Replies

Jolterlast Saturday at 8:31 PM

The linked article states implies they are built:

“These are the first two prototypes — which have already been developed and pre-tested for structural stability and high-voltage performance.”

That’s very weaselly of them.

show 1 reply
seszettlast Saturday at 7:34 PM

I'm sure something like this would be doable and I like the idea, but the stag doesn't seem structurally sound for example.

People generally just want cables to be buried, but apparently this poses more problems than just added cost, so companies are reluctant to do it (as far as I understand it at least, I've only looked it up briefly in relation to the Ventilus/Boucle du Hainaut project here in Belgium).

show 3 replies
abcd_flast Saturday at 11:00 PM

The rule of thumb is that if there's a mention of or a link to the Yanko Design website, you know it's a pipe-dream design concept detached from reality.

Here it features the review by YD, so, yeah, that's not just not built, it's not buildable in principle :)

petrelast Saturday at 7:38 PM

It does. That was my first thought. Buried AC cables are not cost effective, DC is better but still more exprndive than aerial power lines.

show 1 reply