alt Hacker NewsOne of the biggest contributors I've had in the past for SQLite blocking was disk fragmentation.
We had some old Android tablets using our app 8 hours a day for 3-4 years. They'd complain if locking errors and slowness but every time they'd copy their data to send to us, we couldn't replicate, even on the same hardware. It wasn't until we bought one user a new device and got them to send us the old one that we could check it out. We thought maybe the ssd had worn out over the few years of continual use but installing a dev copy of our app was super fast. In the end what did work was to "defrag" the db file by copying it to a new location, deleting the original, then moving it back to the same name. Boom, no more "unable to open database" errors, no more slow downs.
I tried this on Jellyfin dbs a few months ago after running it for years and then suddenly running into performance issues, it made a big difference there too.
Replies
> One of the biggest contributors I've had in the past for SQLite blocking was disk fragmentation.
Is that even still a thing? I thought modern filesystems like ext4 were supposed to be largely immune to that.
That's much more likely flash degradation than actual fragmentation. Did you use cheap tablets with eMMC storage?
This is fascinating. What would be the solution for this? You can’t ask users to defrag.
Copying the file likely forces the creation of a new one with no or lower filesystem fragmentation (e.g. a 1MB file probably gets assigned to 1MB of consecutive FS blocks). Then those FS blocks likely get assigned to flash dies in a way that makes sense (i.e. the FS blocks are evenly distributed across flash dies). This can improve I/O perf by some constant factor. See https://www.usenix.org/system/files/fast24-jun.pdf for instance for more explanation.
I would say that the much more common degradation is caused by write amplification due to a nearly full flash drive (or a flash drive that appears nearly full to the FTL because the system doesn't implement some TRIM-like mechanism to tell the FTL about free blocks). This generally leads to systemwide slowdown though rather than slowdown accessing just one particular file.
This was especially prevalent on some older Android devices which didn't bother to implement TRIM or an equivalent feature (which even affected the Google devices, like the Nexus 7).