logoalt Hacker News

embedding-shapelast Monday at 7:09 PM2 repliesview on HN

> Form ideas without the use of language.

Don't LLMs already do that? "Language" is just something we've added as a later step in order to understand what they're "saying" and "communicate" with them, otherwise they're just dealing with floats with different values, in different layers, essentially (and grossly over-simplified of course).


Replies

heyjamesknightlast Monday at 7:39 PM

But language is the input and the vector space within which their knowledge is encoded and stored. The don't have a concept of a duck beyond what others have described the duck as.

Humans got by for millions of years with our current biological hardware before we developed language. Your brain stores a model of your experience, not just the words other experiencers have shared with yiu.

show 1 reply
deadbabelast Monday at 7:19 PM

LLMs don’t form ideas at all. They search vector space and produce output, sometimes it can resemble ideas if you loop into itself.

show 2 replies