logoalt Hacker News

everdrive11/03/20253 repliesview on HN

This is merely a debate about what it means to "think." We didn't really previously need to disambiguate thinking / intelligence / consciousness / sentience / ego / identity / etc.

Now, we do. Partly because of this we don't have really well defined ways to define these terms and think about. Can a handheld calculator think? Certainly, depending on how we define "think."


Replies

podgorniy11/05/2025

People's failure to articulate the nature of "thinking" is a perfect demonstration of what "thinking" entails

utopiah11/04/2025

> We didn't really previously need to disambiguate thinking / intelligence / consciousness / sentience / ego / identity / etc.

Eh... Plato would like a word with you. Philosophy has been specifically trying to disentangle all that for millennia. Is this a joke?

show 2 replies
richardatlarge11/04/2025

Somebody please get Wittgenstein on the phone

show 1 reply