logoalt Hacker News

celsoazevedolast Monday at 7:41 PM1 replyview on HN

> Even low-band 5G gives you 30–250 Mbps down.

On paper. In practice, it can be worse than that.

I've spent the past year using a network called O2 here in the UK. Their 5G SA coverage depends a lot on low band (n28/700MHz) and had issues in places where you'd expect it to work well (London, for example). I've experienced sub 1Mbps speeds and even data failing outdoors more than once. I have a good phone, I'm in a city, and using what until a recent merger was the largest network in the country.

I know it's not like this everywhere or all the time, but for those working on sites, apps, etc, please don't assume good speeds are available.


Replies

gloosxlast Monday at 10:17 PM

That's really quite odd. There is even no 5G in my area, yet I get 100 Mbps stable download speed on 4G LTE, outdoors and indoors, any time of the day. Is 5G a downgrade? Is it considered normal service in the UK, when latest generation of cellular network provides a connection speed compared to 3G launched in 2001? How is this even acceptable in the year 2025. Would anyone in the UK start complaining if they downgrade it to 100Kbps? Or should we design the apps for that case?

show 1 reply