alt Hacker News> Disagree and push back
The other day an LLM gave me a script that had undeclared identifiers (it hallucinated a constant from an import).
When I informed it, it said "You must have copy/pasted incorrectly."
When I pushed back, it said "Now you trust me: The script is perfectly correct. You should look into whether there is a problem with the installation/config on your computer."
Replies
paxys • yesterday at 1:26 AM
That's the flip side of the same symptom. One model is instructed to agree with the user no matter what, and the other is instructed to stick to its guns no matter what. Neither of them is actually thinking.
➕ show 1 reply
logifail • last Monday at 8:27 PM
There was a time when we'd have said you were talking to a sociopath.
Was it Grok 4 Fast by chance?
I was dealing with something similar with it yesterday. No code involved. It was giving me factually incorrect information about a multiple schools and school districts. I told it it was wrong multiple times and it hallucinated school names even. Had the school district in the wrong county entirely. It kept telling me I was wrong and that although it sounded like the answer it gave me, it in fact was correct. Frustrated, I switched to Expert, had it re-verify all the facts, and then it spit out factually correct information.