logoalt Hacker News

Brian_K_Whitelast Monday at 8:49 PM2 repliesview on HN

If I want to view an image file on a remote machine, and all I have is ssh... I just connect to that machine with filezilla and click on whatever files I want. I can even open files that aren't PNG! Even files that aren't even images at all. Mindblowing.

A terminal with in-band graphics primitives is called an RDP client.

We've had graphics terminals since RIP BBS's and even before that. If they were actually useful enough to be worth the bother, then we'd all have been using them all along and there wouldn't be posts like this.

It's not a case of there's this awesome idea that just for some reason no one knows about. No, it's just not that awesome of an idea. It's not harmful so it doesn't bother me that most xterms support tektronix graphics, it's just a gimmick of no real value. It's a solution to no problem.

Don't believe me? When was the last time you used passthrough printing? Or saw it being used even in some place where they do actually need to print? The terminals all still support it. It's just a thing that you don't need to do in-band in a tty, and today there is no reason to bother doing it that way even though you could. It's not better and does not solve a problem.


Replies

anthklast Monday at 9:02 PM

With sshfs and 'rclone mount' you forget the shell and everything it's a filesystem.

IshKebabyesterday at 7:30 AM

I don't think viewing files is the most compelling use case for this.

> I just connect to that machine with filezilla

"Just" carries a lot of hassle, and this only applies to viewing files.