logoalt Hacker News

eloisantlast Monday at 9:13 PM2 repliesview on HN

This is why I'm very skeptical about the "Nobel prize level" claims. To win a Nobel prize you would have to produce something completely new. LLM will probably be able to reach a Ph.D. level of understanding existing research, but bringing something new is a different matter.


Replies

adamzwassermanlast Monday at 9:57 PM

LLMs do not understand anything.

They have a very complex multidimensional "probability table" (more correctly a compressed geometric representation of token relationships) that they use to string together tokens (which have no semantic meaning), which then get converted to words that have semantic meaning to US, but not to the machine.

show 3 replies
KoolKat23last Monday at 11:15 PM

Given a random prompt, the overall probability of seeing a specific output string is almost zero, since there are astronomically many possible token sequences.

The same goes for humans. Most awards are built on novel research built on pre-existing works. This a LLM is capable of doing.

show 1 reply