alt Hacker NewsPhotocopiers are the opposite of thinking. What goes in, goes out, no transformation or creating of new data at all. Any change is just an accident, or an artifact of the technical process.
Replies
So, if there's a flaw in its sensor and you get somewhat warped output, would you consider it thinking then?
It is the wrong category error.
The proper category error in the context of the discussion would be to say the photocopier is drawing a picture.
It doesn't matter how well or not the photocopier recreates an image. To say the photocopier is drawing a picture is just nonsense and has no meaning.
The same category error as to say the LLM is "thinking".
Of course, the category error could be well exploited for marketing purposes if you are in the business of selling photocopiers or language models.
That's not actually true - try photocopying a banknote with the security pattern on it.