logoalt Hacker News

neom11/04/20251 replyview on HN

I think compression is probably a natural consequence of coherent self models? Isn't requiring other minds to package their intelligence in human interpretable linear narratives is like requiring dolphins to demonstrate intelligence through written language?


Replies

hodgehog1111/05/2025

> compression is probably a natural consequence of coherent self models

I don't think so. The case in the Chinese Room argument is coherent by construction but is not a compression.

> dolphins to demonstrate intelligence through written language

Because LLMs are artificial and not a product of physical evolution, our standards for proving intelligence are much, much higher.

show 1 reply