logoalt Hacker News

gwbas1ctoday at 2:27 PM5 repliesview on HN

Makes me wonder what the difference, in definition, is between a sequencer and a synthesizer? Is this really a synthesizer, or is it really a sequencer?

Yes, I'm splitting hairs about semantics.


Replies

strogonofftoday at 2:49 PM

A synthesizer is generally a higher-level ready-to-use product containing any number of oscillators, sequencers, and other circuits and bells and whistles under the hood. A device with an oscillator and a sequencer qualifies as a basic synth.

At a lower levels you find modules like sequencer, oscillator, etc. They are generally not used by themselves: you plug a sequencer into an oscillator to make use of it, just like a standalone oscillator by itself simply makes a continuous noise that gets old quickly. A synth does that connection for you and exposes the controls.

(To make things even more fun, the lines between lower-level audio modules are often blurred. For example, the difference between a sequencer and an oscillator can be best summed up as: the former is commonly designed for unipolar control rate signal change where you can specify exact level per step, while the latter is designed for bipolar audio rate signal change between two predetermined extremes—however, as the “designed for” hints, you could configure some sequencers to output a bipolar signal changing so fast it is audible, just like you could run a square wave oscillator so slowly that it becomes a 2-step sequencer.)

oidartoday at 2:35 PM

The linked project is both. A synth makes sounds, and a sequencer controls the sound over time usually with note on/off data. This sequencer has 4 steps before looping back to the beginning. To simplify, think of a sequencer as the music box drum and the synth as the tines in a music box.

butliketoday at 2:32 PM

A sequencer is always in steps. A synthesizer has a signal generator and can modulate a single step. This toy is both a synthesizer and a sequencer, but since you cannot toggle the 4 steps off, it will always be a sequencer in addition to the synthesizer

PaulDavisThe1sttoday at 2:29 PM

The answer to your question is "yes".

It is a synthesiser AND it is a step sequencer.

dave_sidtoday at 2:29 PM

Both