logoalt Hacker News

Cities panic over having to release mass surveillance recordings

149 pointsby pavel_lishintoday at 5:23 PM58 commentsview on HN

Comments

belorntoday at 6:32 PM

Here in Sweden, the use of license plate scanners has become the norm for basically all parking houses, bridge tolls and road tolls. Even if you don't install the app or become a "member" of whatever system they are using, the license plate scanners is still used to detect when you enter or leave, and in some cases they automatically look up your home address to send you the bill with zero interaction with the driver. Even if they offer alternative ways to pay, by for example sms, it still uses the license plate scanner when you leave.

The only political party to even mention this as a problem was the pirate party back 15 years ago, and even then it never became a major issue that got discussed. Like paying with credit cards rather than physical cash, people see it as convenience or just as the way things now work.

show 6 replies
dedup-comtoday at 6:01 PM

It must be said that "cities", as used in this piece, is a rather generous term. Sedro-Woolley has 13K residents. Stanwood has 9K. They probably don't have enough people on payroll to handle FOA requests, hence "panic".

show 3 replies
chasiltoday at 7:45 PM

You can find installed Flock cameras around the world with this site:

https://deflock.me/

show 1 reply
tptacektoday at 5:40 PM

They're not panicking about this in Illinois, because Illinois exempts raw ALPR footage from FOIA.

This page is blogspam, though.

show 1 reply
AdamJacobMullertoday at 6:07 PM

I don't understand the correlation here, why does having to release the footage mean that the cities are shutting down the systems?

It seems like they could simply comply with the requirement that footage is public and they can/must share that footage as part of the FOIA process, I don't see much of a downside there and it seems like something which most police departments and municipalities are already doing with footage from other scenarios like body cameras?

show 4 replies
mensetmanusmantoday at 7:57 PM

The truth can hurt, law doesn’t victimize someone for being held accountable.

xnxtoday at 5:47 PM

[flagged]