logoalt Hacker News

rfooyesterday at 6:47 AM7 repliesview on HN

China maintain the view that Tibet is part of China since the establishment of PRC, and they make this very explicit. Same for their border disputes with India. China never admitted that they believe it's not theirs. Mea while China does not ever say that Japan or Korea is part of China (and it's the only reason why they keep North Korea from collapsing despite it being super annoying).

So, again, any example of China suddenly started to claim lands?


Replies

krioryesterday at 7:00 AM

They also claim that the Taiwan-island is part of their territory. Since Its currently full of taiwanese people and China holds regular military exercises around that island an invasion does not seem far-fetched.

show 1 reply
dmurrayyesterday at 9:07 AM

Don't most people maintain the view that Tibet is part of PRC China? They might think further autonomy or independence for it would be a good thing, like the Basque Country, but the control isn't really disputed right now. And nobody really seems to think it should be part of India.

In contrast to Taiwan, where the governments in both Beijing and Taipei officially maintain that those places are part of the same country, and the international community sometimes pretends the same and only recognises one government, but de facto everyone trades with both countries and deals with both governments.

actionfromafaryesterday at 9:07 AM

North Korea is a buffer zone. That's the reason.

thaumasiotesyesterday at 10:05 AM

> Same for their border disputes with India. China never admitted that they believe it's not theirs.

Not an issue I follow, but I did read something that said China had proposed swapping claimed territory for zones of actual control, and India turned them down.

exe34yesterday at 7:04 AM

isn't that the same clever argument that Comrade Vladimir uses in Ukraine?

show 2 replies
testdelacc1yesterday at 8:56 AM

> Perhaps there are not many instances in history where one country has gone out of her way to be friendly and cooperative with the government and people of another country and to plead their cause in the councils of the world, and then that country returns evil for good

Jawaharlal Nehru (India’s Prime Minister), on the day that China launched an unprovoked surprise war against India in 1962. It was a crushing victory for China, and they grabbed all their territory they wanted. More can always be said but here’s a 2 minute video that explains the war - https://youtu.be/zCePMVvl1ek

You know how Mao said diplomacy flows from the barrel of a gun? That wasn’t a metaphor. That is PRC policy since 1949.