logoalt Hacker News

amarantyesterday at 8:04 PM2 repliesview on HN

I find the take a quirk in how the state of the art assistive technology works is reason for privacy fear mongering to be tired, unimaginative, and typical of today's journalism that cares more for clicks than reporting fact.

It's a very interesting quirk of a immensely useful device for those that need it, but it's not an ethical dilemma.

I for one am sick and tired of these so-called ethicists who's only work appear to be so stir up outrage over nothing holding back medicinal progress.

Similar disingenuous articles appeared when stem-cell research was new, and still do from time to time. Saving lives and improving life for the least fortunate is not an ethical dilemma, it's an unequivocally good thing.

Quit the concern trolling nature.com, you're supposed to be better than that


Replies

fsckboyyesterday at 9:08 PM

>it's an unequivocally good thing.

the miracle that is humans and humanity came about through millennia of unrestrained fertility and lots of sex℠ producing many babies, most of whom didn't survive to adulthood. Insects and fish still do this on a grand scale. It's where we came from and who we are, and that's Not Bad™ and I think it's unequivocally a bad thing that we keep thinking we know better and interfering with it. we are failing miserably to propel our species forward for the future. "survival of the fittest" is a mistake, it's destruction of the no-longer-adequate that works the magic.

(pretty proud of myself for realizing after I put in the tm that I could go back and put in a service mark too)

pixl97yesterday at 9:03 PM

This is quite the spicy take for something that could have far more than one purpose.

The problem with humanity is some people pick up the hammer and build a house while others will crack your head open with it and eat the pink gooey insides. The discussion of technology should be able to withstand the good and bad points of its conception.

show 1 reply