logoalt Hacker News

GuB-42today at 5:34 PM1 replyview on HN

I wonder how much of it is just Arthur Conon Doyle hating his character. Which has was known for as the stories progressed. He even killed him, just to resurrect him later because of public demand.

He accumulated character flaws along the way, as if Doyle wanted to make Holmes as unsympathetic as he could without changing his core traits.


Replies

nosianutoday at 6:08 PM

> Arthur Conon Doyle hating his character

But Holmes is not "unsympathetic" in any of the stories, so I don't see your theory matching the facts.

> He accumulated character flaws along the way, as if Doyle wanted to make Holmes as unsympathetic as he could

[citation needed]

I don't even see the first part of that assertion fulfilled, and I read the books multiple times.