Um. Porque no los dos. I think most individuals here would sign up for some sort of systemic approach. That said, it is well within human norms to set some very visible examples to ensure there is a level of understanding of what society deems acceptable. Not that long ago, from history standpoint, some societies took very active view of making sure that stealing hands are removed. I do not advocate returning to that. I do think that an appropriate smack is appropriate.

The amount of copper thieves is finite. The fact that this keeps happening means that, if anything, there isn't enough retribution.