logoalt Hacker News

smeejtoday at 3:09 AM2 repliesview on HN

I think I probably would use a project that had a license that said "you can use this for now, but if I later decide I don't want evil people to use it, you'll have to maintain your own fork based on the last version before I made that decision."

Isn't that kind of always the bargain we're making? We can use someone's work as long as they're willing to let us, but if they change the license, we might not be able to continue using it.


Replies

gus_massatoday at 11:28 AM

All MIT/BSD projects are ike that. The mantainer can get up tomorrow and relicence the sofware. (Keeping some attributions if other persons contributed.) You are free to fork the last free version.

With [A]GPL it's only possible if there are no external contributions or everyone agree. Again, you are free to fork the last free version.

burnt-resistortoday at 5:10 AM

No. Things given away are inanimate and lack agency.