logoalt Hacker News

the_gipsytoday at 10:39 AM2 repliesview on HN

"World's policeman", that's what you tell little kids America was doing. America didn't invade Iraq or Afghanistan for world peace. There were strong economic and strategic motives behind those invasions.

At the same time, soft power is also vanishing.


Replies

pfdietztoday at 12:15 PM

Strategic motivation? If one assumes the US is going to be globally involved, yes, but that's begging the question.

Economic motivation? Not so much now, with the US being a dominant oil producer, and with petroleum itself losing importance. Even then, it's questionable if this could justify the full cost of the US military.

I think the original motivation was two fold: it was a combination of some sort of moral obligation to defend the "free world" from authoritarians, and (after WW2) a desire to keep small countries (and recent WW2 enemies) from deciding their only option for defense was their own nuclear deterrent.

show 1 reply
tim333today at 12:40 PM

"strong economic and strategic motive" behind Afghanistan? They did it to get Bin Laden basically.

America are like a slightly corrupt and violent world police.

show 1 reply