alt Hacker NewsI'd assume most French would be happy with "France detected Lightning on Mars"
I read the title as equivalent to "Humanity detected Lightning on Mars", which I'm also perfectly happy with
Replies
simgt • today at 10:03 AM
I did not think much of the title before reading the parent comment as I also read "humanity", but now it's the lack of consistency and double standards that annoy me. "France detected Lightning on Mars", fine, let's stop cutting the funding of public research so we can keep on saying we. Also let's title "We released GPT-5", "We landed a rocket on a barge".
➕ show 1 reply
The journalist writing the article starts with
> Scientists analyzed 28 hours of recordings over two Martian years, listening for electrical signals.
Not with
> We analyzed 28 hours of recordings over two Martian years, listening for electrical signals.
Nor
> Humanity analyzed 28 hours of recordings over two Martian years, listening for electrical signals.
Somehow it would be weird to assume that "everybody" put the effort into this, but "we" all reap the success.
On the other hand, this is done with taxpayer money, and even if not, it is done in the context of the whole global economy and we are all interconnected and everybody steps on the shoulders of giants anyway, so, in the grand scale of things, a use of "we" can make sense for everything that happens.
Moreover, OP's argument holds also for the france case anyway.