logoalt Hacker News

lazidetoday at 2:02 PM1 replyview on HN

Feelings have physical analogs which are (typically) measurable, however. At least without a lot of training to control.

Shame, anger, arousal/lust, greed, etc. have real physical ‘symptoms’. An LLM doesn’t have that.


Replies

baqtoday at 3:27 PM

LLMs don't really exist physically (except in the most technical sense), so point is kind of moot and obvious if you accept this particular definition of a feeling.

LLMs are not mammals nor animals, expecting them to feel in a mammalian or animal way is misguided. They might have a mammalian-feeling-analog just like they might have human-intelligence-analog circuitry in the billions (trillions nowadays) of parameters.

show 1 reply