logoalt Hacker News

_aavaa_yesterday at 8:30 PM1 replyview on HN

Why shouldn’t it?

Why should we have to buy a whole new computer if we want to upgrade one thing?

The car example is also telling. Yes most people buy pre-built, but the vast majority of pieces can also be bought to repair or replace.


Replies

dedup-comyesterday at 8:40 PM

"Why shouldn't it" does not answer the question, which is "what made desktop computers (and servers, to a certain degree) a unique popular product that customers routinely build out of parts".

I am not questioning repairs (which almost never happen, as PC hardware in general is very robust these days) or upgrades to factory-built PCs (which should account for probably 1% of the PC component retail volume). I am wondering why there is an entire industry selling colorful boxes (as opposed to brown cardboard with a part number) with things that are not usable in any way when taken out of the box and are only functional when combined with 10+ other things in somewhat nontrivial way. Forget about "why shouldn't it" and "it was like this forever" and look at this phenomenon with a fresh eye. This is ridiculous (in a factual way, not saying this judgmentally).

show 2 replies