logoalt Hacker News

karmasimidayesterday at 10:15 PM1 replyview on HN

That is the problem.

AI is optimized to solve a problem no matter what it takes. It will try to solve one problem by creating 10 more.

I think long time/term agentic AI is just snake oil at this point. AI works best if you can segment your task into 5-10 minutes chunks, including the AI generating time, correcting time and engineer review time. To put it another way, a 10 minute sync with human is necessary, otherwise it will go astray.

Then it just makes software engineering into bothering supervisor job. Yes I typed less, but I didn’t feel the thrill of doing so.


Replies

citizenpaulyesterday at 11:30 PM

> it just makes software engineering into bothering supervisor job.

I'm pretty sure this is the entire enthusiasm from C-level for AI in a nutshell. Until AI SWE resisted being mashed into a replaceable cog job that they don't have to think/care about. AI is the magic beans that are just tantalizingly out of reach and boy do they want it.

show 1 reply