logoalt Hacker News

everdrivelast Thursday at 2:50 PM3 repliesview on HN

Do social movements _always_ have people at the top pulling the strings? Is it _never_ the case that even when you can identify thought leaders, the movement itself is organic and broadly supported?


Replies

Larrikinlast Thursday at 3:27 PM

Internet comments aren't a social movement

Everything that these laws are supposedly regulating has always been there and we have an entire generation now that grew up with it. Everyone was fine just like video games were fine, movies were fine, racy books were fine, and the printing press was fine.

The Internet comments make it seem like lazy parents but it's very convenient that the solution is to ID every single person on the Internet. Facebook pushed this hard with their real name policy and then had to back off because people complained about trans people being forced to use their old names. They've been successfully demonized so now it's time to push as hard as they can. It's probably not just Facebook but it's obviously not organic.

show 2 replies
tokailast Thursday at 3:06 PM

This isn't a social movement.

show 2 replies
indoordin0saurlast Thursday at 3:05 PM

Yeah, this is much more easily explained by the fact that a lot of things on the internet are damaging kids.

show 1 reply